Hard-shell favours frequent movement
Quicker opening and closing can matter on trips where the vehicle moves most mornings. A compact closed profile can also simplify everyday touring between camps.
Build Project BriefCampers & Touring · Rooftop tent answer
Hard-shell and soft-shell rooftop tents suit different travel patterns. The useful comparison is not which format is universally better, but which one fits the vehicle and how often camp moves.

Quicker opening and closing can matter on trips where the vehicle moves most mornings. A compact closed profile can also simplify everyday touring between camps.
A soft-shell format can provide generous sleeping area and suit travellers who establish camp for longer. The trade-off can be a more involved deployment and pack-down routine.
Whichever format is preferred, the supporting roof or canopy, rack, total load, mounting area and overall height still need to suit the exact vehicle.
Move from knowledge to project